РУС
ENG
The Institute of Precedent
Precedent Search
Opinions
Judicial Politics
Interviews
Dissents
Law
Science
Academic Works
Legal Journalism
Project Creators
Contacts
Judges
G. Zhilin
Justice of the Constitutional Court since 1999
V. Demidov
Justice of the Supreme Court of Russia since 1993
Subject area
Civil Law
Court Proceedings
Economic activities, finances
International Law
Public Law
Social security
Nikolay Vitrouk
Justice of the Constitutional Court since 1991-2003, Vice-Chairman in 1991-1995.
More detail
Decisions in which the judge dissented
Year
Decision number and date
Subject area
1992
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.05.1992 № 6-П
Legislative procedures
Total for the year 1992:
1 opinions
1993
Conclusion of the Constitutional Court of 23.03.1993 № З-1
Powers of the Russian President
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 03.06.1993 № 13-П
Authorities of the subjects of the Federation
Conclusion of the Constitutional Court of 21.09.1993 № З-2
Powers of the Russian President
Total for the year 1993:
3 opinions
1995
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 10.07.1995 № 9-П
Powers of the subjects of the Federation; elections
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 31.07.1995 № 10-П
Powers of the Russian President; state of emergency and martial law
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.11.1995 № 14-П
Powers of the subjects of the Federation; elections
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.12.1995 № 17-П
Criminal liability; migration rules
Total for the year 1995:
4 opinions
1996
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.01.1996 № 1-П
Civil law; farm households
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 18.01.1996 № 2-П
Powers of the subjects of the Federation
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 01.02.1996 № 3-П
Powers of the subjects of the Federation
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 13.06.1996 № 14-П
Criminal procedure
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.12.1996 № 21-П
Powers of the subjects of the Federation; elections
Total for the year 1996:
5 opinions
1997
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.01.1997 № 1-П
Powers of the subjects of the Federation; local self-government
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.04.1997 № 7-П
Elections; powers of the subjects of the Federation; powers of the Russian President
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.06.1997 № 9-П
Elections; powers of the subjects of the Federation
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.11.1997 № 16-П
Taxes and dues
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 01.12.1997 № 18-П
Social security
Total for the year 1997:
5 opinions
1998
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.03.1998 № 8-П
Customs law; administrative liability
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.04.1998 № 12-П
Elections; powers of the subjects of the Federation
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 10.06.1998 № 17-П
Referenda; local self-government
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.06.1998 № 19-П
Judicial review
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.12.1998 № 28-П
Powers of the Russian President
Total for the year 1998:
5 opinions
1999
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.03.1999 № 5-П
Criminal procedure
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 28.05.1999 № 9-П
Proceedings on administrative offences
Total for the year 1999:
2 opinions
2000
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.01.2000 № 1-П
Criminal procedure
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 07.06.2000 № 10-П
Status and powers of subjects of the Federation
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.07.2000 № 12-П
President of Russia
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.11.2000 № 15-П
Local self-government
Total for the year 2000:
4 opinions
2001
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 22.11.2001 № 15-П
Taxes and dues; powers of the Federal Government
Total for the year 2001:
1 opinions
2002
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 02.04.2002 № 7-П
Local self-government
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 04.04.2002 № 8-П
Status and powers of the subjects of the Federation
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 19.06.2002 № 11-П
Social obligations of the State
Total for the year 2002:
3 opinions
2003
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.01.2003 № 1-П
Judicial review
Total for the year 2003:
1 opinions