Decisions in which the judge dissented

Year	Decision number and date Subject area
1992	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.11.1992 № 9-П Freezing the activities of the Comminist Parties of Russia and of the USSR Total for the year 1992: 1 opinions
1993	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 12.02.1993 № 3-П NGOs Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.05.1993 № 11-П Mass-media; freedom of speech Decree of the Constitutional Court of 03.06.1993 № 13-П Authorities of the subjects of the Federation Decree of the Constitutional Court of 07.06.1993 № 14-П Elections; separation of powers Decree of the Constitutional Court of 10.09.1993 № 15-П Separation of powers between the Federation and its subjects Conclusion of the Constitutional Court of 21.09.1993 № З-2 Powers of the Russian President Total for the year 1993: 6 opinions
1995	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 06.06.1995 № 7-П Labour law Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.06.1995 № 29-О Labour law Decree of the Constitutional Court of 31.07.1995 № 10-П Powers of the Russian President; state of emergency and martial law Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.12.1995 № 17-П Criminal liability; migration rules Total for the year 1995: 4 opinions
1996	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.12.1996 № 21-П Powers of the subjects of the Federation; elections Total for the year 1996: 1 opinions
1997	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.05.1997 № 8-П Customs law; administrative liability Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.11.1997 № 16-П Taxes and dues Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.12.1997 № 21-П Civil law; taxes and dues Total for the year 1997: 3 opinions
1998	Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 14.07.1998 № 86-О Operational investigations Decree of the Constitutional Court of 17.07.1998 № 22-П Taxes and dues Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 26.11.1998 № 144-О Pensions Total for the year 1998: 3 opinions
1999	Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.02.1999 № 18-О Operational investigations Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.03.1999 № 5-П Criminal procedure Total for the year 1999: 2 opinions
2001	Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 16.01.2001 № 1-О Criminal liability Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.01.2001 № 2-П Taxes and dues; powers of subjects of the Federation Decree of the Constitutional Court of 25.04.2001 № 6-П Criminal liability Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.04.2001 № 7-П Customs law; administrative liability Decree of the Constitutional Court of 22.11.2001 № 15-П Taxes and dues; powers of the Federal Government Total for the year 2001: 5 opinions
2003	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.01.2003 № 1-П Judicial review Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.05.2003 № 8-П Banks; court bailiffs Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.10.2003 № 15-П Elections; mass-media; freedom of speech Total for the year 2003: 3 opinions
2004	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.01.2004 № 1-П Judicial review Decree of the Constitutional Court of 03.03.2004 № 5-П National and cultural autonomy Decree of the Constitutional Court of 06.04.2004 № 7-П Powers of the Federal Government Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.04.2004 № 133-О Taxes and dues; powers of the Federal Government Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.04.2004 № 168-О Taxes and dues Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.04.2004 № 169-О Taxes and dues Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.07.2004 № 14-П Taxes and dues Decree of the Constitutional Court of 29.11.2004 № 17-П Elections; local self-government Total for the year 2004: 8 opinions
2005	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 22.03.2005 № 4-П Criminal procedure Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 12.04.2005 № 153-О Taxes and dues Decree of the Constitutional Court of 31.05.2005 № 6-П Insurance Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.07.2005 № 9-П Taxes and dues; administrative liability Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.11.2005 № 402-О Citizenship Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 01.12.2005 № 462-О Social security Decree of the Constitutional Court of 19.12.2005 № 12-П Bankruptcy Decree of the Constitutional Court of 21.12.2005 № 13-П Elections; separation of powers between the Federation and its subjects Total for the year 2005: 8 opinions
2006	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.06.2006 № 7-П Elections; freedom of speech Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 17.07.2006 № 137-О Local self-government Total for the year 2006: 2 opinions
2007	Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.01.2007 № 1-П Representation in courts; contingent fees Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.05.2007 № 380-О-О Criminal liability Decree of the Constitutional Court of 28.06.2007 № 8-П Criminal liability; terrorism Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.12.2007 № 797-О-О Elections; citizenship Total for the year 2007: 4 opinions
2009	Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 02.04.2009 № 484-О-П Public manifestations Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 19.05.2009 № 545-О-О Migration rules Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 02.07.2009 № 1037-О-О Criminal liability Total for the year 2009: 3 opinions