РУС
ENG
The Institute of Precedent
News
News
Nov 9, 2020
Dissents in the Russian Constitutional Court are prohibited from being published
Jan 15, 2020
A full collection of case law of the Civil Cassation Department of the Ruling Senate
In free access for the first time
Precedent Search
Opinions
Judicial Politics
Interviews
Dissents
Law
Science
Academic Works
Legal Journalism
Project Creators
Contacts
Judges
Z. Bespalova
Judge of the Supreme Court of Russia, member of Disciplinary Judicial Bench
A. Kokotov
Justice of the Constitutional Court since 2010
Subject area
Civil Law
Court Proceedings
Economic activities, finances
International Law
Public Law
Social security
Nikolay Bondar
Justice of the Constitutional Court since 2000.
More detail
Decisions in which the judge dissented
Year
Decision number and date
Subject area
2002
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 15.01.2002 № 1-П
Elections
Total for the year 2002:
1 opinions
2004
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.03.2004 № 90-О
Product sharing agreements
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 06.04.2004 № 7-П
Powers of the Federal Government
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.04.2004 № 9-П
Law on federal budget
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 29.11.2004 № 17-П
Elections; local self-government
Total for the year 2004:
4 opinions
2005
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.07.2005 № 8-П
Liability of the State; execution proceedings
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.11.2005 № 10-П
Elections; freedom of speech
Total for the year 2005:
2 opinions
2006
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 17.07.2006 № 137-О
Local self-government
Total for the year 2006:
1 opinions
2007
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.01.2007 № 1-П
Representation in courts; contingent fees
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 01.11.2007 № 948-О-О
Execution of punishments
Total for the year 2007:
2 opinions
2010
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 17.03.2010 № 6-П
Proceedings in commercial courts
Total for the year 2010:
1 opinions
2012
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 14.05.2012 № 11-П
Execution proceedings; housing law
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 28.06.2012 № 1248-О
Criminal procedure
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.10.2012 № 1768-О
Pensions
Total for the year 2012:
3 opinions
2013
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 10.10.2013 № 1485-О
Administrative and criminal liability
Total for the year 2013:
1 opinions
2015
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 04.06.2015 № 13-П
Recovery of losses by the State
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 01.12.2015 № 30-П
Local self-government
Total for the year 2015:
2 opinions
2017
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 26.01.2017 № 203-О
Electoral law; judicial review
Total for the year 2017:
1 opinions