Table of dissenting opinions

Court:
Judge:

Dissenting opinions by judges of the Constitutional Court have been published since the earliest period of its history, that is, from January 1992. Some of them they were designated as merely “opinions”, particularly if an opinion was a concurrence, that is, its author was disagreeing only with the reasoning of the Court, but not with the conclusion it arrived to. In the first years of Court’s activity the publication of dissents was quite messy and poorly organized, and this is the reason why no legal database (even the one of the Court itself) currently offers a full collection of dissents. Therefore, the table below may claim to be the first complete list of dissents for twenty years of Court’s work (1992-2012, excluding the year 1994, in which the Court did not function).

Dissenting opinions shall follow immediately after the text of the decision itself and may be accessed through the respective hyperlink in the left column. The middle column contains the general subject addressed in the Court's decision and judges' dissents attached thereto. In the right column the dissenting judges are listed. Every annual table is complemented with the overall number of dissents for this particular year. See also Biographies of the Constitutional Court judges

Year

Decision number and date

Subject area

Authors

1992

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.01.1992 № 1-П	Powers of the Russian President	Ametistov E.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 04.02.1992 № 2-П	Labour law	Gadzhiev G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 13.03.1992 № 3-П	Status of the subject of the Federation	Ametistov E.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 19.05.1992 № 5-П	Legislative procedures	Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.05.1992 № 6-П	Legislative procedures	Vitrouk N.
Decision of the Constitutional Court of 24.09.1992 № 8-р	Labour law	Gadzhiev G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.11.1992 № 9-П	Freezing the activities of the Comminist Parties of Russia and of the USSR	Luchin V. Kononov A. Ebzeev B.
Total for the year 1992:	9 opinions

1993

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 12.02.1993 № 3-П	NGOs	Kononov A.
Conclusion of the Constitutional Court of 23.03.1993 № З-1	Powers of the Russian President	Ametistov E. Vitrouk N. Morshchakova T.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.04.1993 № 7-П	Labour law	Morshchakova T.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 21.04.1993 № 8-П	Referenda	Morshchakova T. Ametistov E.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.05.1993 № 11-П	Mass-media; freedom of speech	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 03.06.1993 № 13-П	Authorities of the subjects of the Federation	Kononov A. Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 07.06.1993 № 14-П	Elections; separation of powers	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 10.09.1993 № 15-П	Separation of powers between the Federation and its subjects	Kononov A. Morshchakova T.
Conclusion of the Constitutional Court of 21.09.1993 № З-2	Powers of the Russian President	Ametistov E. Vitrouk N. Kononov A. Morshchakova T.
Decision of the Constitutional Court of 01.12.1993 № 88-р	Constitutional Court proceedings	Ebzeev B.
Decision of the Constitutional Court of 01.12.1993 № 89-р	Constitutional Court proceedings	Ebzeev B.
Total for the year 1993:	19 opinions

1995

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.03.1995 № 1-П	Legislative procedures	Luchin V. Rudkin Y. Gadzhiev G. Morshchakova T. Oleynik V.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 12.04.1995 № 2-П	Legislative procedures	Gadzhiev G. Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 06.06.1995 № 7-П	Labour law	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.06.1995 № 29-О	Labour law	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.06.1995 № 8-П	Housing law	Danilov Y.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 10.07.1995 № 9-П	Powers of the subjects of the Federation; elections	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 31.07.1995 № 10-П	Powers of the Russian President; state of emergency and martial law	Ametistov E. Vitrouk N. Gadzhiev G. Zorkin V. Kononov A. Luchin V. Morshchakova T. Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 31.10.1995 № 12-П	Amendments to the federal Constitution	Morshchakova T.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.11.1995 № 14-П	Powers of the subjects of the Federation; elections	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.12.1995 № 17-П	Criminal liability; migration rules	Kononov A. Vitrouk N.
Total for the year 1995:	23 opinions

1996

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.01.1996 № 1-П	Civil law; farm households	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 18.01.1996 № 2-П	Powers of the subjects of the Federation	Vitrouk N. Gadzhiev G. Rudkin Y.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 01.02.1996 № 3-П	Powers of the subjects of the Federation	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.03.1996 № 7-П	Social security	Gadzhiev G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 04.04.1996 № 9-П	Migration rules	Baglay M.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.04.1996 № 11-П	Powers of the subjects of the Federation; powers of the Russian President	Luchin V.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.05.1996 № 13-П	Local self-government	Ametistov E.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 13.06.1996 № 14-П	Criminal procedure	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.10.1996 № 17-П	Taxes and dues; legislative procedures	Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.12.1996 № 21-П	Powers of the subjects of the Federation; elections	Vitrouk N. Morshchakova T. Baglay M. Kononov A.
Total for the year 1996:	15 opinions

1997

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.01.1997 № 1-П	Powers of the subjects of the Federation; local self-government	Gadzhiev G. Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 28.01.1997 № 2-П	Criminal procedure; the bar (advocates)	Luchin V. Ametistov E. Oleynik V. Vedernikov N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 18.02.1997 № 3-П	Taxes and dues	Morshchakova T.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 04.03.1997 № 4-П	Powers of the subjects of the Federation; advertising services	Zorkin V.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.04.1997 № 7-П	Elections; powers of the subjects of the Federation; powers of the Russian President	Vitrouk N. Gadzhiev G. Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.05.1997 № 8-П	Customs law; administrative liability	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.06.1997 № 9-П	Elections; powers of the subjects of the Federation	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.11.1997 № 16-П	Taxes and dues	Vitrouk N. Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 01.12.1997 № 18-П	Social security	Vitrouk N. Morshchakova T.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 10.12.1997 № 19-П	Powers of the subjects of the Federation	Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.12.1997 № 21-П	Civil law; taxes and dues	Kononov A.
Total for the year 1997:	19 opinions

1998

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 15.01.1998 № 2-П	Migration rules	Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.03.1998 № 8-П	Customs law; administrative liability	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 03.04.1998 № 10-П	Housing law	Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 06.04.1998 № 11-П	Legislative procedures	Ametistov E.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.04.1998 № 12-П	Elections; powers of the subjects of the Federation	Strekozov V. Vitrouk N.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.06.1998 № 89-О	Civil procedure	Gadzhiev G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 10.06.1998 № 17-П	Referenda; local self-government	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.06.1998 № 19-П	Judicial review	Vitrouk N. Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 14.07.1998 № 86-О	Operational investigations	Morshchakova T. Kononov A. Gadzhiev G. Oleynik V.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 17.07.1998 № 22-П	Taxes and dues	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 05.11.1998 № 134-О	President of Russia	Morshchakova T.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 17.11.1998 № 26-П	Elections	Vedernikov N.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 26.11.1998 № 144-О	Pensions	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 10.12.1998 № 27-П	Criminal procedure	Luchin V.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.12.1998 № 28-П	Powers of the Russian President	Vitrouk N. Luchin V. Oleynik V.
Total for the year 1998:	22 opinions

1999

Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.02.1999 № 18-О	Operational investigations	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.03.1999 № 5-П	Criminal procedure	Kononov A. Vitrouk N. Morshchakova T.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 28.05.1999 № 9-П	Proceedings on administrative offences	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.11.1999 № 16-П	Religious organisations	Zharkova L.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 01.12.1999 № 17-П	Powers of the Russian President; General Procurator	Luchin V.
Total for the year 1999:	7 opinions

2000

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.01.2000 № 1-П	Criminal procedure	Vitrouk N. Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.04.2000 № 6-П	Judicial review	Zhilin G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 07.06.2000 № 10-П	Status and powers of subjects of the Federation	Vitrouk N. Luchin V.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 27.06.2000 № 92-О	Status and powers of subjects of the Federation	Luchin V.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.07.2000 № 12-П	President of Russia	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.11.2000 № 15-П	Local self-government	Vitrouk N. Gadzhiev G.
Total for the year 2000:	9 opinions

2001

Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 16.01.2001 № 1-О	Criminal liability	Kononov A. Morshchakova T.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.01.2001 № 2-П	Taxes and dues; powers of subjects of the Federation	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.02.2001 № 33-О	Labour law	Zhilin G. Khokhryakova O.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 10.04.2001 № 5-П	Military personnel	Khokhryakova O.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 25.04.2001 № 6-П	Criminal liability	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.04.2001 № 7-П	Customs law; administrative liability	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 03.07.2001 № 10-П	Banks; bankruptcy	Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 22.11.2001 № 15-П	Taxes and dues; powers of the Federal Government	Vitrouk N. Kononov A.
Total for the year 2001:	11 opinions

2002

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 15.01.2002 № 1-П	Elections	Bondar N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 02.04.2002 № 7-П	Local self-government	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 04.04.2002 № 8-П	Status and powers of the subjects of the Federation	Vitrouk N. Gadzhiev G. Morshchakova T. Yaroslavtsev V.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 19.06.2002 № 11-П	Social obligations of the State	Vitrouk N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 22.07.2002 № 14-П	Banks; bankruptcy	Yaroslavtsev V.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 10.12.2002 № 284-О	Taxes and dues; powers of the Federal Government	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 16.12.2002 № 282-О	Banks; forward contracts	Gadzhiev G.
Total for the year 2002:	10 opinions

2003

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.01.2003 № 1-П	Judicial review	Vitrouk N. Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.05.2003 № 8-П	Banks; court bailiffs	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 11.06.2003 № 10-П	Referenda	Luchin V. Yaroslavtsev V.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 30.10.2003 № 15-П	Elections; mass-media; freedom of speech	Gadzhiev G. Kononov A. Yaroslavtsev V.
Total for the year 2003:	8 opinions

2004

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.01.2004 № 1-П	Judicial review	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 03.03.2004 № 5-П	National and cultural autonomy	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.03.2004 № 90-О	Product sharing agreements	Bondar N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 06.04.2004 № 7-П	Powers of the Federal Government	Bondar N. Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.04.2004 № 133-О	Taxes and dues; powers of the Federal Government	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.04.2004 № 169-О	Taxes and dues	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.04.2004 № 168-О	Taxes and dues	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.04.2004 № 9-П	Law on federal budget	Bondar N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 17.06.2004 № 12-П	Banks	Gadzhiev G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.07.2004 № 14-П	Taxes and dues	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 29.11.2004 № 17-П	Elections; local self-government	Kononov A. Bondar N.
Total for the year 2004:	13 opinions

2005

Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.02.2005 № 17-О	Pensions	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.02.2005 № 1-О	Status of judges	Yaroslavtsev V.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 11.03.2005 № 3-О	Status of judges	Ebzeev B.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 11.03.2005 № 148-О	Status of judges	Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 22.03.2005 № 4-П	Criminal procedure	Gadzhiev G. Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 12.04.2005 № 153-О	Taxes and dues	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 31.05.2005 № 6-П	Insurance	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.07.2005 № 8-П	Liability of the State; execution proceedings	Bondar N.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.07.2005 № 9-П	Taxes and dues; administrative liability	Gadzhiev G. Kononov A. Yaroslavtsev V.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.11.2005 № 402-О	Citizenship	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 14.11.2005 № 10-П	Elections; freedom of speech	Bondar N. Gadzhiev G. Krasavchikova L. Mavrin S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 01.12.2005 № 462-О	Social security	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 19.12.2005 № 12-П	Bankruptcy	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 21.12.2005 № 13-П	Elections; separation of powers between the Federation and its subjects	Kononov A. Yaroslavtsev V.
Total for the year 2005:	21 opinions

2006

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 28.02.2006 № 2-П	Regulation of communication industry; taxes and dues	Kleandrov M.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 02.03.2006 № 58-О	Judicial review	Zhilin G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 06.04.2006 № 3-П	Military personnel; criminal procedure	Kazantsev S.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.06.2006 № 7-П	Elections; freedom of speech	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 17.07.2006 № 137-О	Local self-government	Kononov A. Bondar N. Ebzeev B.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 02.11.2006 № 444-О	Taxes and dues	Gadzhiev G.
Total for the year 2006:	8 opinions

2007

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 23.01.2007 № 1-П	Representation in courts; contingent fees	Bondar N. Gadzhiev G. Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 21.03.2007 № 3-П	Referenda	Kazantsev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 19.04.2007 № 205-О-О	Proceedings in commercial courts	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.05.2007 № 380-О-О	Criminal liability	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.05.2007 № 378-О-П	Labour law	Khokhryakova O.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.05.2007 № 370-О-О	Trade marks; competition	Gadzhiev G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.05.2007 № 6-П	Criminal procedure	Kazantsev S.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 28.06.2007 № 8-П	Criminal liability; terrorism	Gadzhiev G. Kononov A. Ebzeev B.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.07.2007 № 11-П	Political parties	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 01.11.2007 № 948-О-О	Execution of punishments	Bondar N.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.12.2007 № 797-О-О	Elections; citizenship	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.12.2007 № 959-О-О	Social security	Khokhryakova O.
Total for the year 2007:	16 opinions

2008

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 16.07.2008 № 9-П	Criminal procedure	Zhilin G.
Total for the year 2008:	1 opinions

2009

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 27.02.2009 № 4-П	Civil procedure; dispositive legal capacity	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 05.03.2009 № 467-О-О	NGOs	Kazantsev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 02.04.2009 № 484-О-П	Public manifestations	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 19.05.2009 № 545-О-О	Migration rules	Kononov A.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 24.06.2009 № 11-П	Competition	Kazantsev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 02.07.2009 № 1037-О-О	Criminal liability	Kononov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 19.11.2009 № 1344-О-Р	Criminal liability	Rudkin Y.
Total for the year 2009:	7 opinions

2010

Decree of the Constitutional Court of 21.01.2010 № 1-П	Proceedings in commercial courts	Zhilin G. Kleandrov M.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 28.01.2010 № 2-П	Joint-stock companies	Melnikov N.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 03.02.2010 № 149-О-О	Labour law	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 03.02.2010 № 148-О-О	Criminal procedure	Gadzhiev G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 17.03.2010 № 6-П	Proceedings in commercial courts	Bondar N. Gadzhiev G. Rudkin Y.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 19.04.2010 № 8-П	Criminal procedure; terrorism	Gadzhiev G. Yaroslavtsev V.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 01.06.2010 № 840-О-О	Labour law; elections	Knyazev S.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 08.06.2010 № 13-П	Housing law; minors	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 17.06.2010 № 904-О-О	Taxes and dues	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 16.12.2010 № 1650-О-О	Labour law; execution proceedings	Aranovskiy K.
Total for the year 2010:	14 opinions

2011

Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 18.01.2011 № 2-О-О	Proceedings in commercial courts	Zhilin G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.02.2011 № 192-О-О	The bar (advocates)	Aranovskiy K. Yaroslavtsev V.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 01.03.2011 № 283-О-О	Status of judges	Yaroslavtsev V.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 17.05.2011 № 8-П	Military personnel; social security	Zhilin G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 18.05.2011 № 9-П	Local self-government	Yaroslavtsev V. Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 26.05.2011 № 727-О-О	Medical treatment and patients' rights	Gadzhiev G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 26.05.2011 № 10-П	Arbitration tribunals	Aranovskiy K.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 07.06.2011 № 751-О-О	Criminal procedure	Kazantsev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 07.06.2011 № 842-О-О	Social security	Kazantsev S.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 09.06.2011 № 12-П	Status of judges; operational investigations	Kleandrov M.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 21.06.2011 № 872-О-О	Family law; statute of limitations	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 05.07.2011 № 879-О-О	Taxes and dues; charity	Aranovskiy K.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 19.07.2011 № 17-П	Civil procedure	Zhilin G. Zharkova L.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.07.2011 № 19-П	Status of judges	Aranovskiy K. Kleandrov M.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.07.2011 № 20-П	Federal budget	Gadzhiev G.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 22.11.2011 № 25-П	Civil service	Aranovskiy K. Knyazev S.
Decree of the Constitutional Court of 20.12.2011 № 29-П	Air transportation; minors	Gadzhiev G.
Total for the year 2011:	22 opinions

2012

Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 17 January 2012 № 174-О-О	Criminal procedure; judicial dissents	Gadzhiev G. Zhilin G. Knyazev S. Kleandrov M.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 07.02.2012 № 276-О-О	State regulation of prices	Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 09.02.2012 № 2-П	Labour law; social security	Aranovskiy K. Kazantsev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 22.03.2012 № 447-О-О	Constitutional Court proceedings	Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 27.03.2012 № 8-П	International treaties	Zhilin G. Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 30.03.2012 № 9-П	Housing law; privatisation	Zhilin G. Kazantsev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 11.05.2012 № 712-О	Status of judges; the bar (adocates)	Kokotov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 11.05.2012 № 713-О	Status of judges	Kokotov A.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 14.05.2012 № 11-П	Execution proceedings; housing law	Bondar N. Zhilin G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.05.2012 № 880-О	Family law	Knyazev S. Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 18.05.2012 № 12-П	Public manifestations	Yaroslavtsev V.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 27.06.2012 № 15-П	Dispositive legal capacity	Zhilin G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 28.06.2012 № 1274-О	Criminal procedure	Aranovskiy K.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 28.06.2012 № 1248-О	Criminal procedure	Bondar N.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 17.07.2012 № 1289-О	Political parties	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 17.07.2012 № 1286-О	Administrative liability	Knyazev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.10.2012 № 1768-О	Pensions	Bondar N.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.10.2012 № 1911-О	Civil law; land law	Kleandrov M.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 16.10.2012 № 22-П	Criminal procedure	Knyazev S.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 26.11.2012 № 28-П	Customs law; administrative liability	Knyazev S. Melnikov N. Aranovskiy K.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 30.11.2012 № 29-П	Civil procedure	Zhilin G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 27.12.2012 № 34-П	Status of the members of the State Duma and the Council of the Federation	Kokotov A. Gadzhiev G.
Total for the year 2012:	33 opinions

2013

Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 17.01.2013 № 1-О	Civil procedure; jurisdiction	Zhilin G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 17 January 2013 № 1-П	Antitrust; administrative liability	Kokotov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 24.01.2013 № 119-О	Privatisation; land	Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 14.02.2013 № 4-П	Public manifestations; administrative liability	Danilov Y. Kazantsev S. Yaroslavtsev V.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 05.03.2013 № 413-О	Customs law	Aranovskiy K.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 05.03.2013 № 353-O	Education	Aranovskiy K. Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 05.03.2013 № 5-П	Taxes and dues	Aranovskiy K.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 06.03.2013 № 324-O	Political parties	Knyazev S. Kokotov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 21.03.2013 № 421-О	Labour law	Kokotov A.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 14.05.2013 № 9-П	Pensioners; social benefits	Aranovskiy K.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 21.05.2013 № 10-П	Criminal procedure	Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 23.05.2013 № 11-П	State due; licensing	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 04.06.2013 № 900-O	Administrative liability; reputation	Rudkin Y. Zhilin G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 25.06.2013 № 14-П	Criminal proceedings	Zhilin G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 02.07.2013 № 16-П	Criminal proceedings	Kazantsev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 16.07.2013 N 1241-О	Local self-government	Kokotov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 24.09.2013 N 1341-О	Civil law; real estate	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 10.10.2013 № 1485-О	Administrative and criminal liability	Bondar N. Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 07.11.2013 № 1713-О	The status of judges	Kleandrov M.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 02.12.2013 № 26-П	Constitutional judicial review	Gadzhiev G.
Total for the year 2013:	26 opinions

2014

Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 14.01.2014 № 7-O	Election rights	Knyazev S.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 08.04.2014 № 10-П	Non-commercial organisations	Yaroslavtsev V.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 15.04.2014 № 11-П	Early voting	Kazantsev S. Danilov Y.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 05.06.2014 № 1211-O	Criminal law; State service	Kokotov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 24.06.2014 № 1350-O	Civil law and religion	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 03.07.2014 № 1555-О	Land tax; cadastre	Aranovskiy K.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 11.12.2014 № 32-П	Criminal liability	Aranovskiy K.
Total for the year 2014:	8 opinions

2015

Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 24.03.2015 № 5-П	Housing law	Yaroslavtsev V. Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 31.03.2015 № 6-П	Judicial review; tax authorities	Zhilin G. Danilov Y.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 04.06.2015 № 13-П	Recovery of losses by the State	Bondar N.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 23.06.2015 № 1518-O	Social benefits for families	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 02.07.2015 № 1536-П	Administrative liability	Aranovskiy K.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 16.07.2015 № 1787-О	Civil proceedings	Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 16.07.2015 № 23-П	Criminal proceedings	Gadzhiev G. Danilov Y. Kazantsev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 06.10.2015 № 2443-O	Criminal procedure	Aranovskiy K.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 20.10.2015 № 27-П	Civil proceedings	Zhilin G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 19.11.2015 № 2732-O	Administrative liability	Knyazev S.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 01.12.2015 № 30-П	Local self-government	Kokotov A. Bondar N.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 08.12.2015 № 2740-O	Citizenship	Aranovskiy K.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 17.12.2015 № 33-П	Criminal proceedings	Aranovskiy K.
Total for the year 2015:	18 opinions

2016

Rulings of the Constitutional Court of 14.01.2016 №№ 134-О и 135-О	Social protection	Kazantsev S.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 15.02.2016 № 3-П	Law of obligations	Gadzhiev G.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 17.02.2016 № 5-П	Migration rules	Aranovskiy K. Kokotov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 10.03.2016 № 450-О	Election law	Knyazev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 10.03.2016 № 443-О	Property law	Kazantsev S.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 19.04.2016 № 12-П	Status of ECHR decisions in Russia	Aranovskiy K. Yaroslavtsev V. Kazantsev S.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 26.04.2016 № 13-П	Local self-government	Kokotov A.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 31.05.2016 № 14-П	Taxes and public dues	Gadzhiev G.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 06.06.2016 № 1232-О	Criminal proceedings	Kokotov A.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 23.06.2016 № 1411-О	Election law	Knyazev S.
Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 05.07.2016 № 15-П	Local self-government	Aranovskiy K.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 07.07.2016 № 1358-О	Election law	Aranovskiy K. Knyazev S.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 15.09.2016 № 1742-О	Election law	Gadzhiev G.
Total for the year 2016:	17 opinions

2017

Judgment of the Constitutional Court of 19.01.2017 № 1-П	Execution of ECHR judgments	Yaroslavtsev V. Aranovskiy K.
Ruling of the Constitutional Court of 26.01.2017 № 203-О	Electoral law; judicial review	Bondar N. Kokotov A.
Total for the year 2017:	4 opinions

Judges

Subject area

Table of dissenting opinions